You can view the page at http://forums.sfreader.com/content.p...y-John-Gardner

Comments ported from original posting:

Posted by Erica on 5/23/2005
Yeah grendal is a wonderful and helpful story. And that story about the people in a cave is by Plato. Um, yeah.

Posted by Jonathan Barberena on 10/11/2003
This is a beutiful written novel because it showed a relationship to all mankind and how we all acted uncivilized just for greed. The whole novel kind of had an exerpt of another story one that i cant recall, is about people who were chained in a cave that all the years they saw shadows and believed that the shadows were the real thing because thas all they saw. Is the same as Grendal he for the first time was afraid of everything. There were 12 chapters in the story wich were related to the 12 constalations.The signs scorpio, geminie, and etc. it had many meanings and a diffrent point of view about grendal not as an evil creature but as a person like one of us.

Comments ported from original posting:

Posted by Erica on 5/23/2005
Yeah grendal is a wonderful and helpful story. And that story about the people in a cave is by Plato. Um, yeah.

Posted by Jonathan Barberena on 10/11/2003
This is a beutiful written novel because it showed a relationship to all mankind and how we all acted uncivilized just for greed. The whole novel kind of had an exerpt of another story one that i cant recall, is about people who were chained in a cave that all the years they saw shadows and believed that the shadows were the real thing because thas all they saw. Is the same as Grendal he for the first time was afraid of everything. There were 12 chapters in the story wich were related to the 12 constalations.The signs scorpio, geminie, and etc. it had many meanings and a diffrent point of view about grendal not as an evil creature but as a person like one of us.

Comments ported from original posting

Posted by Erica on 5/23/2005
Yeah grendal is a wonderful and helpful story. And that story about the people in a cave is by Plato. Um, yeah.

Posted by Jonathan Barberena on 10/11/2003
This is a beutiful written novel because it showed a relationship to all mankind and how we all acted uncivilized just for greed. The whole novel kind of had an exerpt of another story one that i cant recall, is about people who were chained in a cave that all the years they saw shadows and believed that the shadows were the real thing because thas all they saw. Is the same as Grendal he for the first time was afraid of everything. There were 12 chapters in the story wich were related to the 12 constalations.The signs scorpio, geminie, and etc. it had many meanings and a diffrent point of view about grendal not as an evil creature but as a person like one of us.

Posted by Erica on 5/23/2005
Yeah grendal is a wonderful and helpful story. And that story about the people in a cave is by Plato. Um, yeah.

Posted by Jonathan Barberena on 10/11/2003
This is a beutiful written novel because it showed a relationship to all mankind and how we all acted uncivilized just for greed. The whole novel kind of had an exerpt of another story one that i cant recall, is about people who were chained in a cave that all the years they saw shadows and believed that the shadows were the real thing because thas all they saw. Is the same as Grendal he for the first time was afraid of everything. There were 12 chapters in the story wich were related to the 12 constalations.The signs scorpio, geminie, and etc. it had many meanings and a diffrent point of view about grendal not as an evil creature but as a person like one of us.

Posted by Erica on 5/23/2005
Yeah grendal is a wonderful and helpful story. And that story about the people in a cave is by Plato. Um, yeah.

Posted by Jonathan Barberena on 10/11/2003
This is a beutiful written novel because it showed a relationship to all mankind and how we all acted uncivilized just for greed. The whole novel kind of had an exerpt of another story one that i cant recall, is about people who were chained in a cave that all the years they saw shadows and believed that the shadows were the real thing because thas all they saw. Is the same as Grendal he for the first time was afraid of everything. There were 12 chapters in the story wich were related to the 12 constalations.The signs scorpio, geminie, and etc. it had many meanings and a diffrent point of view about grendal not as an evil creature but as a person like one of us.